Moonlit Motive

A Moonlight Hollow Mystery

3.91 11 Goodreads ratings

266 pagesPublished 19 February 2026Kindle, paperback & hardcoverParanormal Cozy Mystery

When baker Ivy Bloom inherits a tumbledown cottage in the village of Moonhaven, she expects sourdough, solitude, and a fresh start. She gets a ghost.

Edgar Pike has been haunting the cottage on Wicker Close since 1892. He rearranges the crockery, rotates the ceramic owl, and maintains the building’s ancient magical wards with the fussy dedication of a Victorian surveyor who takes his afterlife very seriously. He and Ivy are just learning to coexist when the village archivist drops dead at the autumn market, and Ivy finds a silver charm in the grass that shouldn’t be there.

The charm is a weapon. The death wasn’t natural. And the secrets buried beneath Moonhaven’s picturesque green could tear the town apart.

Armed with her great-aunt’s coded notebooks, a sourdough starter named Gerald, and the spectral assistance of a ghost who can manage about three words on a good day, Ivy must unravel a web of altered records, dormant property rights, and centuries-old family feuds, before the killer comes for the evidence she doesn’t yet know she’s holding.

Moonlit Motive is the first book in The Moonlight Hollow Mysteries, a paranormal cozy mystery series featuring a baker with an unexpected gift, a ghost with opinions, and a village with more secrets than it has residents.

Perfect for fans of: Juliet Blackwell, Amanda Flower, Bailey Cates, Darynda Jones, and Jenn McKinlay.

Read the first chapter

Chapter One: Arrival in Moonhaven

The road into Moonhaven narrowed without warning, as if the town had decided long ago that anyone who needed directions probably didn’t belong. Ivy Bloom eased her foot off the accelerator and let the car coast between a corridor of silver birch trees, their pale trunks catching the late-afternoon light like rows of candles. Her GPS had given up ten minutes ago, politely, with a soft chime and a blank blue screen, and she was navigating by the hand-drawn map the solicitor had mailed along with the keys.

The map was optimistic. It showed three landmarks: a stone bridge, a church spire, and a star labeled “your cottage” in cheerful purple ink. Ivy had crossed the bridge two turns back. The spire rose ahead of her now, needle-sharp above the treeline, and she felt a cautious loosening in her chest, the first sign in months that her body believed something might go right.

She’d packed the car like someone fleeing a natural disaster, except instead of emergency supplies, she’d brought three boxes of baking equipment, two suitcases of clothes she’d barely looked at in a year, and a sourdough starter named Gerald who was riding shotgun in a sealed jar. Gerald had survived the collapse of her catering business, the loss of her commercial kitchen lease, and six weeks on her sister’s kitchen counter where he’d been mistaken twice for expired yogurt. If Gerald could endure all that, Ivy figured she could endure a new town.

The birches gave way to hedgerow, and then the hedgerow opened onto a view that made her brake harder than she intended. Gerald sloshed against his jar.

Moonhaven sat in a shallow valley like something painted on a biscuit tin. A wide green, actual village green, not a euphemism for a car park, spread at the center, bordered by stone-fronted shops and cottages in shades of honey, cream, and weathered grey. Window boxes trailed ivy and late-season geraniums. A clock tower rose at the north end of the green, its face showing ten past four, and beneath it a handful of market stalls were being assembled by people who moved with the unhurried confidence of folk who’d done this a thousand times. Beyond the rooftops, low hills rolled eastward under a sky that was already thinking about sunset.

It was. , almost offensively picturesque.

She followed the road down the slope and into what passed for the town center: a single through-road that bent gently around the green, lined with angled parking spots and a post office that doubled, according to its hand-lettered sign, as a tea room, a dry cleaner, and a notary public. She pulled into a spot near the clock tower, turned off the engine, and sat for a moment with her hands on the wheel.

Quiet. Not the quiet of her old flat, which had been the exhausted silence of someone too tired to turn on music. This was an alive quiet, birds threading through it, a dog barking somewhere behind the shops, the tap-tap of a mallet on wood from the market stalls. The air coming through her cracked window smelled like cut grass and something baking, and Ivy’s stomach tightened with a complicated feeling she recognized as the ghost of professional instinct. Cinnamon, she thought. And brown butter. Someone in this town knew what they were doing.

She grabbed the solicitor’s map and climbed out. Her legs were stiff from four hours on winding roads, and she stretched beside the car with the self-consciousness of someone who suspects they’re being watched. The green was larger than it had looked from the hill, a generous oval of well-kept grass bordered by a gravel path and wooden benches worn smooth by decades of sitting. A war memorial stood at one end, modest and clean. At the other, the market stalls were taking shape: canvas canopies in deep blues and greens, wooden frames slotted together with practiced efficiency, crates of stock waiting to be unpacked. Everything about the scene spoke of tradition, of a thing done the same way, in the same place, by people who knew their part in it.

Ivy was not, she reminded herself, one of those people. She was a stranger with a dead great-aunt’s key in her pocket and a sourdough starter named Gerald fermenting gently in the passenger seat. She should keep expectations realistic.

She was right to suspect she was being watched. Across the green, a woman in a fitted navy jacket was directing two men carrying a trestle table, but her attention had swiveled toward Ivy with the precision of a lighthouse beam.

Ivy offered a small wave. The woman’s gaze lingered, appraising, not unfriendly, before she turned back to the table situation with a crisp instruction Ivy couldn’t quite hear.

Right. Warm welcome later, possibly. Cottage first.

According to the map, her inheritance sat on the eastern edge of the green, down a lane called Wicker Close. Ivy followed the path on foot, leaving the car to be unpacked once she’d confirmed the place was real and not, as her sister had cheerfully predicted, a pile of rubble with a mailbox. The lane was narrow, paved in uneven flagstones, and lined with cottages that leaned toward each other like old friends sharing a secret. Most had front gardens in various states of ambition, one all roses, another mostly weeds with a single defiant sunflower, a third given over entirely to garden gnomes arranged in what appeared to be a battle formation.

Halfway down the lane, a man in a canvas apron was unloading crates from a handcart parked outside a cottage whose ground floor had been converted into a shop. The window display held bundles of dried flowers, stacked jars of honey in shades from pale gold to almost amber, and a chalkboard sign that read “Bramble &amp. Thyme - Local Goods, Fair Prices, No Refunds on Prophecies.” Ivy wasn’t sure whether the last part was a joke.

The man noticed her and straightened, pushing a straw-colored fringe off his forehead. He was young, late twenties, maybe, with the kind of open, amiable face that suggested he’d never met a stranger he couldn’t talk to for twenty minutes.

“New arrival or lost tourist?” he called out.

“New arrival,” Ivy said. “I think. I’m looking for the cottage at the end of the lane.”

His eyebrows lifted. “Tilda’s place? You’re the grand-niece.” It wasn’t a question. Ivy was beginning to notice that very little in Moonhaven required a question mark. “Felix Carrow. I run Bramble and Thyme, provisions, preserves, and the occasional unsolicited opinion. Anything you need to settle in, you come find me.”

“Ivy Bloom. And thank you, I might take you up on that.”

Felix grinned and hefted another crate. “You will. The nearest proper shop is in Barrowfield, which is either fifteen minutes or forty depending on which road the council’s decided to dig up that week.” He paused, studying her with a curiosity that was direct but not unkind. “She talked about you, you know. Tilda. Said you had good hands.”

Ivy didn’t know what to do with that. She’d met the woman once, at age nine, and her clearest memory was of being offered a ginger biscuit that tasted like it had been baked by someone who understood flour on a molecular level. “I’m a baker,” she said, because it was the simplest true thing, even though she wasn’t sure it was still true.

“A baker.” Felix’s grin widened. “Oh, Dulcie’s going to love that. Or hate it. Possibly both. Welcome to Moonhaven, Ivy.”

He returned to his crates with a cheerful wave, and Ivy continued down the lane carrying the strange warmth of being expected somewhere she’d never been.

Ivy’s cottage was the last on the lane, set slightly apart from its neighbors behind a low stone wall and a wooden gate that had once been painted blue. The paint had mostly surrendered to the weather, leaving soft, peeling curls of color that gave the gate a pleasantly shabby look. She fitted the key the solicitor had sent, an actual iron key, heavy and old-fashioned, into the gate latch and pushed.

The garden was small and overgrown, but not unloved. Someone had maintained it once: there were the bones of herb beds along the path, a stone birdbath listing gently to port, and a climbing rose that had taken over the left side of the cottage façade with the quiet determination of a plant that knew no one was going to stop it. The cottage itself was stone, the same warm honey-grey as the rest of the town, with a slate roof, two upstairs windows, and a front door painted the same faded blue as the gate.

Ivy stood on the path and let herself look.

Great-Aunt Tilda. She’d met the woman exactly once, at a family gathering when Ivy was nine. Her memory was impressionistic at best: a tall woman with silver rings on every finger, a laugh like a crow’s, and the unsettling habit of finishing other people’s sentences. Ivy’s mother had described Tilda as “eccentric but harmless,” which in the family lexicon meant she’d never married, lived alone, and did something no one could adequately explain.

And now Ivy had her cottage. No mortgage, no lease, no landlord, just an iron key and a building that smelled, when she opened the front door, of lavender and cold stone and the particular stillness of a house that had been waiting.

The front door opened directly into a sitting room. Ivy had expected dust sheets and gloom, but the room was merely dim, its curtains drawn but not dusty. The furniture was old but solid: a wingback chair by the fireplace, a small sofa draped with a crocheted blanket, shelves lining one wall and filled with books whose spines she couldn’t yet read. A braided rug covered most of the stone floor. The fireplace was swept clean.

The air was cool and still, carrying that particular scent of old stone houses, mineral and faintly sweet, like rain on warm rock. Beneath it, Ivy caught something else: herbs, dried and dusty, and the ghost of wood smoke that had soaked into the walls over decades of winter fires. It smelled, she thought, like a place that had stories in it. The kind of place that had been deeply, specifically someone’s, and was now, improbably, hers.

She pulled the curtains open. Light flooded in, warm and golden, and Ivy saw that the room was, well, charming was the word, if she was being generous. Cluttered, if she was being honest. The shelves held not just books but jars of dried herbs, glass paperweights, a taxidermied owl that she hoped was decorative and not a former pet, and a collection of maps rolled into tubes and stacked like logs.

The cottage’s layout revealed itself as she explored, and it was, she decided, peculiar. Not wrong, exactly, but arranged according to a logic she couldn’t follow. The sitting room led to a short hallway that took an unnecessary turn before reaching the kitchen. A door she expected to be a cupboard opened onto a narrow staircase. Another door, on the opposite wall, led to a second hallway that circled back to the sitting room, a loop that seemed designed less for convenience than for, what? Ivy stood in the hallway and frowned. It felt like the cottage had been arranged to guide movement in a certain way, the way a maze channels a mouse, except the mouse in this case was a tired thirty-two-year-old who just wanted to find the kettle.

The kitchen, when she finally reached it through the correct sequence of doors, was the best room in the house. It was larger than the sitting room, with a flagstone floor, a deep ceramic sink under a window overlooking the back garden, and a wooden worktable scarred with decades of use. The range was ancient, an oil-fired Aga, bottle green, radiating a low warmth that told Ivy someone had kept it ticking over even after Tilda’s death. The shelves here held copper pans, mixing bowls in graduated sizes, and a row of stoneware crocks labeled in faded handwriting: “Flour,” “Sugar,” “Salt,” and one that simply said “No.”

Ivy touched the worktable’s surface. The wood was smooth, worked to a soft sheen by years of use. She could feel the grooves where a knife had scored it, the faint rings left by hot pans. It was the kind of surface she’d dreamed of in her rented kitchen in the city, where the counters had been laminate and the oven had two settings: barely warm and actively hostile.

Something in her chest shifted. Not quite hope, she’d learned to be careful with hope, but its cousin. Possibility, maybe. The sense that this kitchen could become something, given time and flour and the willingness to show up at five in the morning when no one was watching.

She’d get Gerald settled first. Then she’d explore upstairs. Then, maybe, she’d bake something.

Unloading the car took the better part of an hour. The baking equipment went into the kitchen, where it covered every available surface and most of the floor. The suitcases went upstairs to the larger of the two bedrooms, a low-ceilinged room with a brass bed, a wardrobe that smelled of cedar, and a window that looked out over the back garden toward the hills. Gerald went on the kitchen counter in a spot of late sunlight.

By the time she’d finished, the light had turned amber and the shadows in the cottage had grown long. Ivy stood in the kitchen, slightly breathless, and noticed something she’d missed during her first pass: the temperature in the house was uneven. The kitchen was warm, the Aga saw to that, but the hallway between the kitchen and sitting room held a distinct pocket of cold air that didn’t track with any draft she could find. She’d walked through it three times now, and each time the chill had raised the fine hairs on her forearms.

Old house, she told herself. Stone walls. Probably a gap somewhere she’d find when she wasn’t hauling boxes.

She’d also noticed that the sitting room seemed to rearrange itself when she wasn’t looking. Not dramatically, she wasn’t losing her mind, but small things. A book she was certain had been flat on the shelf was now upright. The crocheted blanket on the sofa had shifted from draped to folded. The taxidermied owl had rotated approximately fifteen degrees to the left, which Ivy attributed firmly to the vibration of her footsteps on the old floor and absolutely nothing else.

She made herself a cup of tea using supplies from the last petrol station and sat at the kitchen worktable. The window above the sink framed a view of the back garden and, beyond the low wall, a strip of the town green. She could see the market stalls taking shape in the fading light: canopies going up, strings of bulbs being tested, vendors carrying crates and calling to each other in voices that carried in the still air. The Moonlit Market. She’d read about it in the solicitor’s letter, a monthly evening market that was, apparently, the social and economic heartbeat of Moonhaven.

The series

The Moonlight Hollow Mysteries

  1. Moonlit Motive
    Book 1Moonlit Motive 3.91 · 11 Goodreads ratingsYou are here
  2. Haunted Theater Hush
    Book 2Haunted Theater Hush 4.50 · 6 Goodreads ratings
  3. Whispers in the Stacks
    Book 3Whispers in the Stacks 4.80 · 5 Goodreads ratings
Wren Holloway

About the author

Wren Holloway

The Keeper of Moonlit Secrets

Wren Holloway writes light paranormal cozy mysteries filled with magical towns, chatty ghosts, and cleverly concealed motives. Her stories blend classic cozy whodunits with gentle supernatural twists, offering fair-play clues, quirky communities, and mysteries that stay comforting rather than dark.

More about Wren Holloway